This is a question we find a lot of our customers asking, especially after having walked around a trade show. There are, of course, many different ways to build to the Passive House standard and many types of insulation but from my experience some are better than others.
There has been a rush from manufacturers of insulation materials to design buildings to achieve the thermal and airtightness requirements of Passive House. However, many of them are very light weight and ignore the fundamentals of what makes a comfortable building with a pleasant internal environment.
The thermal mass contained in a building makes a significant difference to how the building behaves when heat is either captured (from sunlight coming through windows) or produced internally by cooking, tumble drying, vacuuming and from electrical devices. Some people will dispute this as the assessment tool for Passivhaus, known as PHPP, takes account of all of this. However, it appears rather conservative on this area and occupants of the certified passivhaus buildings that are in existence in the UK mention over heating as their only concern. Most of these buildings are made from relatively high thermal mass materials so it remains to be seen how lighter weight buildings will perform.
The same principles apply to passivhaus buildings as any other in that a more thermally massive building will be more comfortable in our variable climate. Materials such as wood fibre insulation or Porotherm blocks (perforated clay blocks) have high mass, high specific heat capacity and store large quantities of heat. Standard masonry also works well although it does release heat rather quicker. These materials and systems absorb internal heat gains, buffering internal temperatures changes and making for a more comfortable environment.
Lightweight insulation is not necessarily a problem in high performance buildings but you are then more reliant on an environmental system that can regularly adjust temperatures, either by heating or cooling. Again, this is perfectly possible but the whole point of building at this high standard is that you reduce your energy consumption by not relying equipment so much. When you build at this level of insulation it really is amazing how much heat we produce, both from appliances and from simple chores like vacuuming.
One final point is about simplicity. The more simple the design is the easier it is to build and the more likely you are to achieve your targets. Another benefit of using natural materials is that you can build simple, solid, unventilated structures without any concern about moisture. Here is one of our most popular and simple timber frame designs, it is a slender wall and roof but has low U-values, very good air tightness and is arguably the most simple way to build with timber frame.
So, when you are deciding on what sort of materials and systems to use in your Passive House building just remember, simplicity is the key.
Let me know what you think by commenting below.